I'm guessing you like the RS Aizawa because the mesh in the lid matches with the mesh in your hood and bumper. That is a nice touch but I think I like the shape of the Zoom lid with your exterior. The mesh detail is not as noticeable from a distance but the shape of the Zoom lid is.
I like the Zoom luggage rack, especially with your description of the functionality. It looks like it would work with a trunk spoiler as well. As for leaving it on semi-permanently, I think it could grow on me . . . and it is. Functionality always has a way of subconsciously influencing how much I like styling details.